Your favourite loudspeaker is not a design methodology. In this short video, about two and a half minutes, I explain why the speakers in a cinema should be an outcome of the performance you want and the money you have to achieve it, rather than the place you start.

Engineering doesn't start with raw materials

That's not how engineering works. When a car is designed, nobody begins by saying they're going to use this type of aluminium, or this particular leather on the seats. You start with the concept: what kind of car are we going to build?

Then you go through design. Then you go through engineering. Only then do you come to specification, where you pick all the individual elements that bring the totality of the experience to life.

A cinema works the same way. I talked through how we apply that sequence in Every Decision Defensible, and why the products in our rooms come out of the engineering in Engineering Before Equipment.

Three problems with a glowing review

Say you watch a random YouTube video and someone gives a speaker a really, really good personal review.

Number one, that's that person's opinion.

Number two, you don't know what their level of expectation is. It might be very high, but being popular on YouTube doesn't necessarily make someone an expert.

Number three, it might work for them, in their particular room, for their particular set of requirements, in that particular scenario. But how do you have any clue it's going to work for you?

Start with what you want to achieve

So the first question is: what do I want to achieve? What is it that I actually want to build in my room?

Write down the things that are important to you, because at the end of the day everything is going to be a balance of compromises. For most people the two biggest constraints are how much money they have and how much space they have.

Dynamics, timbre and spatial

When we wrote CEDIA RP22, we drew a wheel. It shows how you can balance three things:

That wheel is a really fantastic guide to figuring out what you need and, specifically, how much money you want to spend.

Work forward to the product

Your choice of loudspeaker should be an outcome of the level of performance you want to achieve, and how much money you've got to achieve it.

So don't start with the speaker. Start with engineering specifications. Those specifications will help you choose all the equipment in the system, and they'll help you avoid really, really expensive mistakes.

Work forward to the specification of a product. Don't buy the product first and then figure out what you're going to do with it. Our earlier piece Equipment Comes Last, Not First looks at what goes wrong when that order is reversed.

Frequently asked questions

How should I choose speakers for a home cinema?

Start with what you want to achieve, not with a speaker. Decide what you want to build in your room and write down what matters most to you. Then work through design and engineering to a set of engineering specifications. Those specifications should guide the choice of loudspeakers and every other piece of equipment in the system.

Can I rely on a YouTube review to choose a loudspeaker?

A review can be useful, but it has limits. It is one person's opinion, you don't know what their level of expectation is, and being popular on YouTube doesn't necessarily make someone an expert. A speaker that works for them in their room, for their requirements, gives you no guarantee it will work in yours.

What are the biggest constraints when designing a home cinema?

Every home cinema is a balance of compromises. The two biggest constraints for most people are how much money they have and how much space they have.

What is the CEDIA RP22 wheel?

When CEDIA RP22 was written, its authors drew a wheel showing how a system can balance dynamics, timbre and spatial performance. Dynamics is the difference between quiet and really loud. Timbre is how natural things sound. Spatial is how the sound envelops you and how specific sounds can come from specific places. It is a useful guide to working out what you need and how much you want to spend.

Who is Peter Aylett?

Peter Aylett is Client Director of Cinema Buro, a private cinema design practice. He is one of the authors of the international standards the private cinema industry is now measured against, and has designed and calibrated reference-grade rooms for some of the most demanding clients in the world.

About the author

Peter Aylett is Client Director at Cinema Buro. He is a globally recognised authority in private cinema engineering and one of the authors of the international standards the industry is now measured against. He translates clients' ambitions into an engineered brief that the rest of the team can build to with certainty.

Read the full video transcript

[00:00] Your favourite loudspeaker is not a design methodology. That's not how things work. That's not how engineering works. Engineering doesn't start with the raw materials. When a car is designed, they don't go, all right, we're going to use this type of aluminium, or we're going to use this particular leather on the seats. You start with the concept. What kind of car are we going to build?

[00:22] You then go through design. You then go through engineering, and then you come to specification, where you pick all the individual elements that are going to bring that totality of the experience to life. If you watch a random YouTube video and someone gives a speaker a really, really good personal review, well, number one, that's that person's opinion. Number two, you don't know what their level of expectation is.

[00:49] They might have a very high level of expectation, but just because they're popular on YouTube does not necessarily make them an expert. And number three, well, it might work for them, in their particular room, for their particular set of requirements, in that particular scenario. But how do you have any clue it's going to work for you? So the first thing to start with is, well, what do I want to achieve?

[01:12] What is it that I actually want to build in my room? And then write down the things that are important to you, because at the end of the day, everything is going to be a balance of compromises. And the two biggest constraints you're probably going to have are going to be how much money have you got and how much space have you got?

[01:31] When we wrote RP22, we drew a wheel, and that wheel shows how you can balance dynamics, that's the difference between quiet and really loud; timbre, that's how natural things sound; and spatial, which is how that sound envelops you and how specific sounds can come from specific spaces. And that's a really, really fantastic guide in figuring out what do you need and, specifically, how much money do you want to spend?

[01:58] So your choice of loudspeaker should be an outcome of the level of performance that you want to achieve, and how much money you've got to achieve it. Don't start with the speaker. Start with engineering specifications, and those engineering specifications will then help you to choose all the equipment in the system, and will help you not make really, really expensive mistakes.

[02:23] So work forward to specification of a product. Don't buy the product first and then figure out what you're going to do with it.

← All insights Cinema Buro — engineering the room, not the kit.